The Indian automotive market has witnessed a surge in CNG-powered vehicles, with compact SUVs emerging as a popular choice. Two prominent contenders in this segment are the Tata Punch CNG and the Hyundai Exter CNG. Both models offer a compelling blend of affordability, practicality, and fuel efficiency. Let’s delve into a detailed comparison of these two rivals to help you make an informed decision.
Price Point Comparison
Pricing is a crucial factor for budget-conscious buyers. The Tata Punch CNG holds a slight advantage in terms of starting price, with its base variant being approximately Rs. 1.27 lakh cheaper than the Hyundai Exter CNG. However, the top-end Punch CNG variant is pricier by around Rs. 47,000 compared to the Exter CNG’s top trim.
Dimensions and Space
While both the Punch and Exter are compact SUVs, there are subtle differences in their dimensions. The Punch is marginally longer and wider, offering a slightly more imposing stance. However, the Exter takes the lead in terms of height and wheelbase, potentially translating to a more spacious cabin and better headroom.
Powertrain Performance
Both the Punch and Exter CNG are equipped with 1.2-liter naturally aspirated petrol engines that have been adapted for CNG fuel. The Punch boasts slightly higher power and torque figures, delivering a marginally peppier performance. However, the difference in power output is likely to be minimal in real-world driving conditions. Both models come paired with a 5-speed manual transmission.
In terms of fuel efficiency, the claimed mileage figures for both cars are quite close, indicating comparable fuel economy.
Feature Comparison
Both the Tata Punch CNG and Hyundai Exter CNG offer a decent feature set, with some overlapping amenities and unique offerings.
Features shared by both models:
- Automatic climate control
- Power windows
- Steering-mounted audio controls
- Height-adjustable driver’s seat
- Rear parking sensors
Key features of the Tata Punch CNG:
- Alloy wheels (higher variants)
- Push-button start/stop
- Rain-sensing wipers
- Automatic headlights
Key features of the Hyundai Exter CNG:
- Larger 8-inch infotainment system
- Six airbags
- Tyre pressure monitoring system (TPMS)
- Rear AC vents
Verdict: Punch vs Exter CNG
The choice between the Tata Punch CNG and Hyundai Exter CNG boils down to individual preferences and priorities. If you prioritize a slightly lower starting price, a more powerful engine, and features like alloy wheels and push-button start, the Punch CNG might be a better fit. However, if you value a larger infotainment system, additional safety features like multiple airbags and TPMS, and a more premium feel, the Exter CNG could be a more compelling option.
It’s essential to test drive both models to determine which one offers the best driving experience and aligns with your specific needs and preferences.
FAQs
Which car has a bigger boot space, the Tata Punch CNG or the Hyundai Exter CNG?
While specific boot space figures for the CNG variants are not readily available, the standard petrol versions suggest that the Punch might offer slightly more cargo capacity due to its larger dimensions.
Do both cars offer automatic transmission options?
No, both the Tata Punch CNG and Hyundai Exter CNG are currently offered with manual transmission only.
Which car has a better ground clearance?
The Tata Punch generally has a higher ground clearance compared to the Hyundai Exter, making it more suitable for rough road conditions.
