In the ever-evolving electric vehicle (EV) market, choosing the perfect car can be a daunting task. Tata Motors, a leading Indian automaker, offers two compelling options – the Tata Punch EV and the Tata Tigor EV. Both EVs boast impressive features and competitive pricing, making it difficult to decide which one suits your needs best. This comprehensive comparison between the Tata Punch EV Empowered Plus S Medium Range (MR) and the Tata Tigor EV XZ Plus Lux will shed light on their key specifications, features, and unique selling points, empowering you to make an informed decision.
Sizing Up the Contenders: Dimensions and Space
Tata Punch EV: With a length of 3857 mm, width of 1742 mm, and height of 1633 mm, the Punch EV falls under the compact SUV category. This translates to a slightly smaller footprint compared to the Tigor EV. However, its boxy design offers a more spacious feel on the inside. The Punch EV boasts a best-in-class boot space of 366 liters, with an additional 14 liters of frunk storage, making it ideal for weekend getaways or carrying luggage for a small family.
Tata Tigor EV: The Tigor EV, classified as a compact sedan, measures 3993 mm in length, 1677 mm in width, and 1532 mm in height. While it offers a slightly larger overall footprint than the Punch EV, its lower height might translate to less headroom for taller passengers. The Tigor EV provides a boot space of 316 liters, which is sufficient for most everyday needs.
In a nutshell: The Punch EV offers a more spacious interior and invulnerable cargo capacity with its SUV design and additional frunk storage, while the Tigor EV provides a slightly larger overall footprint.
Under the Hood: Powertrains and Performance
Battery and Range: Both the Punch EV MR and Tigor EV come equipped with similarly sized Lithium-ion battery packs, offering a claimed driving range of up to 315 km (according to ARAI for Tigor EV and MIDC for Punch EV). This range is suitable for daily commutes and even occasional weekend trips within a moderate distance.
Power and Torque: While the battery packs are similar, the Punch EV emerges victorious in terms of power output. It boasts an electric motor that delivers 82 PS of power and 114 Nm of torque. The Tigor EV, on the other hand, offers 75 PS of power and a higher torque output of 170 Nm. This translates to a potentially zippier acceleration for the Punch EV, while the Tigor EV’s higher torque might provide a stronger pulling power.
In a nutshell: The Punch EV offers a slight edge in terms of power output, suggesting potentially better acceleration, while the Tigor EV boasts a higher torque figure, which could translate to a stronger pulling power. Both EVs offer a comparable driving range.
Charging Options: Filling Up Your EV
Both the Tata Punch EV MR and Tata Tigor EV offer similar charging options:
50 kW DC Fast Charger: Using a public 50 kW DC fast charger, both EVs can be juiced up from 10% to 80% battery capacity in around an hour, making them suitable for long journeys with readily available charging stations.
Home Wall Box AC Charger: For convenient home charging, both EVs can be plugged into a 7.2 kW AC wall box charger, although the exact charging time is not specified for the Punch EV in the provided information. However, both EVs are expected to take approximately 9.4 hours for a full charge from 10% to 100% using a home AC charger.
In a nutshell: Both EVs offer convenient charging options with DC fast charging and AC home charging capabilities.
Feature Face-Off: Comfort, Convenience, and Technology
Here’s a breakdown of the key features offered by each EV:
Tata Punch EV Empowered Plus S MR
Exterior: The Punch EV boasts a sportier look with auto-LED projector headlights with LED DRLs, welcome and goodbye animation with DRLs, sequential turn indicators, and 16-inch alloy wheels.
Comfort & Convenience: The Punch EV provides automatic climate control, a cooled glovebox, ventilated front seats, multimode regenerative braking, paddle shifters for braking regen modes, drive modes (City & Sport), cruise control, push-button start/stop, electrically adjustable ORVMs with auto-folding function, auto-dimming IRVM, and USB Type-C fast charging ports.
Safety: The Punch EV prioritizes safety with 6 airbags, a 360-degree camera with blind view monitor, electronic stability control, hill hold assist, ABS with EBD, tire pressure monitoring system, ISOFIX child seat anchorage, rear parking sensors, rain-sensing wipers, and a rear wiper with auto defogger.
Tata Tigor EV XZ Plus Lux
Exterior: The Tigor EV offers a more elegant sedan design with auto-halogen projector headlights with LED DRLs, and 14-inch steel wheels with styled covers.
Interior: Similar to the Punch EV, the Tigor EV features leatherette seat upholstery, a leather-wrapped steering wheel, a cooled glovebox, multimode regenerative braking, drive modes (City & Sport), steering-mounted controls, cruise control, push-button start/stop, electrically adjustable ORVMs with auto-folding function, a semi-digital driver’s display, and a 7-inch touchscreen infotainment system with wired Android Auto & Apple CarPlay.
Comfort & Convenience: The Tigor EV offers automatic climate control, height-adjustable driver’s seat, multimode regenerative braking, drive modes (City & Sport), steering-mounted controls, cruise control, push-button start/stop, electrically adjustable ORVMs, day/night IRVM, and USB charging ports.
Safety: The Tigor EV prioritizes safety with dual front airbags, ABS with EBD, tire pressure monitoring system, rear parking camera, rear parking sensors, ISOFIX child seat anchorage, rain-sensing wipers, and a rear wiper with washer and defogger.
In a nutshell: The Punch EV boasts a more feature-rich package with a sunroof, air purifier, larger touchscreen infotainment system, wireless phone charger, ambient lighting, a digital driver’s display, and a 360-degree camera with blind view monitor. The Tigor EV offers a simpler feature set but still provides essential comfort and convenience features.
The Verdict: Choosing Your Perfect EV
- Both the Tata Punch EV Empowered Plus S MR and the Tata Tigor EV XZ Plus Lux are compelling options in the electric vehicle segment. Here’s a quick recap to help you decide which EV aligns best with your needs:
Choose the Tata Punch EV if:
- You prefer a compact SUV design with more cargo space and headroom.
- You prioritize a sportier look and a feature-rich cabin with a sunroof, air purifier, larger touchscreen infotainment system, wireless phone charger, ambient lighting, and a digital driver’s display.
- You value a 360-degree camera with a blind view monitor for enhanced safety.
