More good than bad: Critics differ over Mafia: Definitive Edition

More good than bad: Critics differ over Mafia: Definitive Edition

Mafia: Definitive Edition was released today, September 25, on PC (Steam), PS4, and Xbox One. At the same time, reviews of the game from specialized media appeared on the Web. Estimates of the remake fluctuate greatly – some editions put nine points, while others about six.

Mafia1

On Metacritic, the PC version of Mafia: Definitive Edition scores 78 out of 100 after 25 reviews. With PS4, almost the same – 76 points, and 21 reviews. Critics who tested the project on Xbox One gave 82 points, but there are fewer reviews – only 10. Below are excerpts from the materials of journalists.

Windows Central (90 out of 100): “Powerful characters, detailed storytelling, and stunning graphics make Mafia: Definitive Edition one of the best story-driven games of the year. “

Jeuxvideo.com (80 out of 100): “Mafia is finally back to its former glory, and this remake is a good starting point for those looking to immerse themselves in a more forgiving game. At the same time, fans will appreciate the makeover, which does not betray the original experience, although it feels dated in places. “

Gamer.nl (65 out of 100): “Mafia: Definitive Edition is enough to bring back fond memories, but it won’t let newbies understand why the original is considered legendary. “

4Players.de (57 out of 100): “The remake stays true to the original, but the mechanics and narrative feel terribly dated, giving the impression that this is a remaster that has failed to reach its full potential. “